not really, the 1.6A can do some whopin speeds that an XP can never beat
some XP's are not cheaper than 1.6A's here, if you're overclockin, the 1.6A is the right route, if not, XP then
That argument might have been right a few months ago, but since the Northwood, Intel is leapin away, c'mon K8!!
btw the .13 mircon core from AMD ain't all that better, might be good for up to round 2.2GHz (could be wrong, but thats the way it looks now) and the XP is rumored to be a .18 and .13 hybrid already, so only K8 looks to be in the runnings with future northwoods.
Hey, i'm gunning for AMD too, but gotta give credit where credit's due!